A legacy bibliography for the anomalistic paleontology of the Paluxy River (Glen Rose, Texas), 1939-2024

by Noah J. Edmonds

NOTE: The following paper is a draft of a project being prepared for submission to the Occasional Papers of the Dallas Paleontological Society for a special issue on the Paluxy River. This draft serves as a preprint for peer review, commentary, and editing before submission/publication.

INTRODUCTION
The Paluxy River in Glen Rose, Texas, has been a focal point of anomalistic paleontology ever since its famous dinosaur tracks were uncovered following a major flood of the Brazos River in the early 1900s. The most well-known (and most contentious) claims have revolved around purported human footprints discovered alongside those of dinosaurs – assertions that have fueled debate for decades. This region has been a battleground for two opposing views: proponents of out-of-place artifacts/fossils who argue for either a recent creation or an extreme antiquity of humans, and proponents of mainstream geology and paleontology who reject these claims as misinterpretations or fabrications. The controversy, primarily driven by young Earth creationists, has generated a significant body of research, ranging from rigorous analysis to speculative theorizing. Despite the ongoing debate, a comprehensive and updated bibliography of sources on these anomalistic finds has yet to be published.

In creating this bibliography, I’ve drawn from several key sources. The TalkOrigins Archive offers several specialized bibliographies on the Paluxy River, ichnology, and “man tracks”, though these are brief and not intended to be comprehensive, nor do they cover the wider spectrum of anomalistic finds associated with the river. By far, the most thorough list remains Paul Heinrich’s 1996 compilation, which encompasses general geology, paleontology, and the then-emerging field of dinosaur track ichnology. While invaluable, Heinrich’s list has become a victim of its age: compiled before the rise of digital archives (especially those specific to creation science issues such as CORE Academy’s Creation-Evolution Literature Database or Creation Education’s Research Assistance Database), it lacks accessibility to many original sources and is missing critical updates from the last thirty years.

This updated bibliography addresses these gaps by focusing on the anomalous claims surrounding the Paluxy River and incorporating material published since Heinrich’s work. Additionally, I have prioritized the accessibility of sources, including links to online versions wherever possible (aside from those materials that remain undigitized or are difficult to obtain due to being published in the private press). The bibliography is organized into four main sections:

  • Pro-Anomalistic Sources: These references argue that out-of-place finds, such as human footprints alongside dinosaur tracks, or trilobites, or fossilized human remains etc., have been discovered in the Paluxy River and offer defenses of these claims.
  • Critical Sources: These references present mainstream scientific perspectives on the supposed anomalies, providing more conventional explanations for the findings and challenging the validity of the pro-anomalistic claims.
  • Appendix A – Miscellaneous Sources: This section lists sources that could not be located but were worth mentioning for their relevance, or sources that are unique on their own, including John Morris’ back-and-forth retraction of the human track narrative on behalf of the Institute for Creation Research in the 1980s only for his organization to tacitly endorse the tracks in the modern day.
  • Appendix B – Newspaper References: Heinrich’s original bibliography included a handful of newspaper articles that discussed the Paluxy human-track narrative. I’ve expanded this selection to include additional articles and have provided links to online archives, such as those managed by the Houston Public Library system, wherever possible.

This new reference list serves not only as a contemporary update to Heinrich’s work, but also as a comprehensive resource for researchers interested in the complex and controversial history of the Paluxy River’s anomalistic paleontology. I’ve arranged the sources in chronological order to help the reader tracks sources or look for certain sources by year, using alphabetical organization for authors published during the same year.

Keywords: anomalistic paleontology, Paluxy River, human footprints, dinosaur tracks, out-of-place finds, young-Earth creationism, ichnology

PRO-ANOMALISTIC SOURCES

Articles

Rakowsky, A. (2022) Tracking Humans on the Cretaceous Rocks of Texas’ Paluxy River. The Kolbe Center for the Study of Creation.

Ensign, D. (2009) Book Review: The Global Phenomenon of Human Fossil Footprints in Rock by Aaron Judkins. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 46(2), 92.

Ensign, D. (2006) Book Review: Secrets of the Ica Stones and Nazca Lines by Dennis Swift. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 43(3), 178-179.

Fields, W., Miller, H., Whitmore, J., Davis, D., Detwiler, G., Ditmars, J., Whitelaw, R., Novaez, G. (1990) The Paluxy River Footprints Revisited. Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism, 2, 155-176.

Dahmer, L., Kouznetsov, D., Ivenov, A., Hall, J., Whitmore, J., Detwiler, G., Miller, H. (1990) Report on Chemical Analysis and Further Dating of Dinosaur Bones and Dinosaur Petroglyphs. Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism, 2, 371-374.

Baugh, C. (1989) Academic Justification for Voluntary Inclusion of Scientific Creation in Public Classroom Curricula, Supported by Evidence that Man and dinosaurs were Contemporary [Doctoral Dissertation, Pacific College of Graduate Studies]. Creation Evidence Museum.

Rosnau, P. O., Auldaney, J., Howe, G. F., Waisgerber, W. (1989) Are Human and Mammal Tracks Found Together With the Tracks of Dinosaurs in the Kayenta of Arizona? Part I: A History of Research and a Site Description. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 26(2), 41-48.

Gish, D. (1989) More Creationist Research (14 Years) – Part I: Geological Research. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 25(4), 161-169.

Anonymous. (1988) Preliminary Analysis of Paluxy Tooth. Bible-Science Newsletter, 26(4), 14.

DeVilbiss, J. W. (1986) The Discovery of Quasi-Human Ichnofossils in the Glen Rose Dolomite, Paluxy River, Texas. Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism, 2, 227-232.

Mehlert, A. W. (1986) Diluviology and Uniformitarian Geology – A Review. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 23(3), 104-109.

Morris, J. D. (1986) Identification of Ichnofossils in the Glen Rose Limestone, Central Texas. Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism, 1, 89-92.

DeVilbiss, J. W. (1985) Did Humans and Dinosaurs Live Together in Texas? Maybe. Origins Research, 8(2), 8-12.

Baugh, C. E. (1984) Human Footprints. Creation Magazine, 5(2), 4-5.

Hinderliter, H. (1984) Observations on the Paluxy Evidences. Bible-Science Newsletter, 22(12), 5.

Hinderliter, H. (1984) An Evaluation of the Latest Anti-Creationist Paluxy Program. Bible-Science Newsletter, 22(12), 1-2.

Anonymous (1984) CNB 700 Club. Creation ex nihilo Technical Journal, 6(4), 35.

Anonymous (1983) Creation Museum. Creation ex nihilo Technical Journal, 6(2), 30.

Lang, W. (1983) Lab Test Report in on Hammer! Paluxy Progress. Bible-Science Newsletter, 21(12), 1, 13.

Lang, W. (1983) Footprints in Texas; Possible Dinosaur Skeletons in San Antonio Area; Modern Hammer in Silurian Rocks. Bible-Science Newsletter, 21(6), 14.

Anonymous (1982) New Fossil Man Footprints from Paluxy? Creation ex nihilo Technical Journal, 5(2), 40.

Batz, P. (1982) The Importance of These New Discoveries: Paluxy Enigma. Bible-Science Newsletter, 20(6), 2.

Batz, P. (1982) Paluxy: New Site, New Tracks, New Interest. Bible-Science Newsletter, 20(6), 1.

Dougherty, C. (1982) Late Update: Paluxy River Report. Bible-Science Newsletter, 20(12), 13.

Morris, J. (1982) Man and Dinosaur Tracks! Where are They? Creation ex nihilo Technical Journal, 4(4), 21-25.

Parker, G. (1981) Origin of Mankind. Acts and Facts, 10(11).

Burdick, C. L. (1980) Dinosaurs and Human Footprints Side-by-Side. Bible-Science Newsletter, 18(2), 3-5.

Lubenow, M. L. (1980) Significant Fossil Discoveries Since 1958: Creationism Confirmed. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 17(3), 148-160.

Beierle, F. P. (1979) A New Kind of Evidence from the Paluxy. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 16(2), 87-88, 131.

Beierle, F. P. (1979) Paluxy River Report. Bible-Science Newsletter, 17(4), 4.

Burdick, C. (1976) Re: Neufeld: Dinosaur tracks and giant men (Origins 2:64-76). Origins, 3(1), 7-8.

Morris, J. (1976) The Paluxy River Tracks. Acts & Facts, 5(5).

Gish, D. T. (1975) A Decade of Creationist Research. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 12(1), 34-46.

Taylor, S. E. (1971) The Mystery Tracks in Dinosaur Valley. Bible-Science Newsletter, 9(4), 1-7.

Burdick, C. L. (1950) When GIANTS Roamed the Earth: Their Fossil Footprints Still Visible! Signs of the Time, 77(28), 8-9.

Books and Chapters

Beierle, F. P. & Adolfi, J. (2024) Giant Man Tracks (3rd Ed.) Lost World Museum.

Dougherty, C. N. & Adolfi, J. (2023) Valley of the Giants (9th Ed.) Lost World Museum.

Fleming, J. N. & Caldwell, B. (2022) Dinosaur Tracks and Human Footprints: Evidence of the Creation Model in the Fort Worth Basin, A Paradigm Shift from the Evolutionary Model. Newton Notes Publishing.

Rife, P. (2013) Bones of Contention: Uncovering the Hidden Truth about America’s Lost Race of Giants. America Star Books.

Woetzel, D. (2013) Chronicles of Dinosauria: The History and Mystery of Dinosaurs and Man. Master Books, p. 28.

Petersen, D. (2012) Unlocking the Mysteries of Creation. Creation Resource Publications, pp. 154-161.

Judkins, A. (2010) The Global Phenomenon of Human Fossil Footprints in Rock. Lulu.

Judkins, A. (2009) Evolution and Human Fossil Footprints. Bible Belt Publishing.

Helfinstine, R. F. & Roth, J. D. (2007) Texas Tracks and Artifacts: Do Texas Fossils Indicate Coexistence of Men and Dinosaurs? (Rev. Ed.). R&J Publishing.

Wilson, C. & Wilson, B. (2007) The Paluxy River Dinosaur Controversy: Did Dinosaurs and Men Walk Together? Final Nails in the Coffin of Evolution. Pacific Christian Ministries.

Gray, J. (2003) Lost World of the Giants. Jonathan Gray, pp. 38-40.

Zillmer, H. J. (2002) Darwin’s Mistake: Antediluvian discoveries prove: dinosaurs and humans co-existed. Adventures Unlimited Press Frontier Publishing, pp. 11-14, 21-28, 32-40, 64, 96, 151.

Rife, P. (2001) The Goliath Conspiracy. iUniverse.

Chick, J. T. (2000) In the Beginning [Gospel tract]. Chick Publications, p. 10.

Baugh, C. E. (1999) Why do Men Believe Evolution Against All Odds? Bible Belt Publishing.

Helfinstine, R. F. & Roth, J. D. (1994) Texas Tracks and Artifacts: Do Texas Fossils Indicate Coexistence of Men and Dinosaurs? R&J Publishing.

Parker, G. E. (1994) Creation: Facts of Life. Master Books.

Baugh, C. E. & Wilson, C. (1992) Footprints and the Stones of Time: Scientific Evidence that Man and Dinosaurs Walked the Earth Together. Hearthstone Publishing, Ltd.

Baugh, C. & Wilson, C. (1991) Dinosaur: Scientific Evidence That Dinosaurs And Men Walked Together (2nd Ed.). Promise Publishing, Inc.

Baugh, C. (1989) Panorama of Creation. Southwest Radio Church.

Baugh, C. & Wilson, C. (1987) Dinosaur: Scientific Evidence That Dinosaurs and Men Walked Together. Promise Publishing, Inc.

Wilson, C. (1985) Creation or Evolution: Facts or Fairytales – Answering Young People’s Questions. Pacific College Incorporated.

McDowell, J. & Stewart, D. (1984) The Creation. Here’s Life Publishers.

Morris, H. (1984) A History of Modern Creationism. Master Books, pp. 83, 122, 239, 251-252, 284-285, 369.

Fields, W. (1980) Paluxy River Explorations: 1977-1979 (Rev. Ed.).

Morris, J. D. (1980) Tracking Those Incredible Dinosaurs & The People Who Knew Them: The fascinating case for the co-existence of dinosaurs and human beings. Bethany House.

Steiger, B. (1979) Worlds before Our Own. Penguin Publishing Group, pp. 3, 45-50, 109.

Gish, D. (1978) Dinosaurs: Those Terrible Lizards. Master Books.

Beierle, F. P. (1977) Man, Dinosaurs and History. Perfect Printing Co.

Kofahl, R. E. (1977) Handy Dandy Evolution Refuter. Beta Books, pp. 68-71.

Dougherty, C. N. (1976) Valley of the Giants. Bennett Printing Co.

Moore, J. (1976) Questions and Answers on Creation/Evolution. Baker Book House, pp. 80, 100.

Wysong, R. L. (1976) The Creation-Evolution Controversy: Implications, Methodology and Survey of Evidence. Inquiry Press, pp. 373-377.

Segraves, K. L. (1975) The Great Dinosaur Mistake. Beta Books.

Wilder-Smith, A. E. (1975) Man’s Origin, Man’s Destiny: A Critical Survey of the Principles of Evolution and Christianity. Bethany Fellowship, pp. 135-139, 293-298.

Beierle, F. P. (1974) Giant Man Tracks. Perfect Publishing.

Creation Research Society (1974) Biology: A Search for Order in Complexity. Zondervan, 426-428.

Gish, D. T. (1974) Have You Been…Brainwashed? Institute for Creation Research.

Daly, R. (1972) Earth’s Most Challenging Mysteries. The Craig Press, pp. 192-193.

Nevins, S. E. (1971) Stratigraphic Evidence of the Flood. In A Symposium on Creation (Vol. 3), pp. 32-65. Baker Book House.

Burdick, C. (1970) Footprints on the Sands of Time: A Defense Statement. Bible-Science Association.

Whitcomb, J. C. & Morris, H. M. (1961) The Genesis Flood: The Biblical Record and Its Scientific Implications. Baker Book House, pp. 167, 173-175.

Films and Audio

Juby, I. [wazooloo] (2022, March 26) Dinos & Humans VI, part 30, The Complete Creation, 3rd edition [Video]. YouTube.

Juby, I. [wazooloo] (2022, March 26) Dinos and Humans V, Part 29, The Complete Creation 3rd edition [Video]. YouTube.

Juby, I. [wazooloo] (2022, March 26) Dinos and Humans IV, part 28 The Complete Creation 3rd edition [Video]. YouTube.

Juby, I. [wazooloo] (2022, March 15) Dinos and Humans III, Part 27, the Complete Creation, 3rd edition [Video]. YouTube.

Juby, I. [wazooloo] (2022, March 15) Dinos and Humans II, Part 26 The Complete Creation 3rd Ed [Video]. YouTube.

Juby, I. [wazooloo] (2022, March 15) Dinos and Humans, Part I, The Complete Creation, 3rd edition, part 25 [Video]. YouTube.

Baugh, C. E. (1996) Creation in Symphony: The Evidence [VHS Tape Set]. Creation Evidence Museum. (Partial transcript available from Called Out Believers)

Baugh, C. E. (1996) Creation in Symphony: The Model – Companion Set to “Creation in Symphony: The Evidence” Video Tape Series [VHS Tape Set]. Creation Evidences Museum.

Cheshire, J. & Cote, B. (1996) The Mysterious Origins of Man [Film]. NBC.

Baugh, C. E. (1983) Enemies Survived Together for a While [Video Tape]. Genesis Institute/International Bible College.1

Whitcomb, J. C. (1979) Dinosaurs and Men: Tape 3 [Audio Casette]. Grace Theological Seminary.

Tucker, R. T. (1978) Footprints and Feet in Oklahoma. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 14(4), 226.

Taylor, S. E. (1970) Footprints in Stone [Film]. Films for Christ.

CRITICAL SOURCES2

Articles

Kuban, G. J. (2022) A Brief History of the Paluxy “Man Track” Controversy. paleo.cc.

Kuban, G. J. (2022) A Matter of Degree: An Examination of Carl Baugh’s Alleged Credentials. paleo.cc.

Kuban, G. J. (2022) ICR Continues to Disseminate Misinformation on Paluxy Tracks. paleo.cc.

Kuban, G. J. (2022) The Three Main Paluxy “Man Track” Phenomena. paleo.cc.

Lallensack, J. N., Owais, A., Falkingham, P. L., Breithaupt, B. H., Sander, P. M. (2022) How to verify fossil tracks: the first record of dinosaurs from Palestine. Historical Biology, 35(6), 924-934.

Senter, P. J. (2022) Dinosaur Bones and Radiocar-bunkum. Skeptical Inquirer, 46(6).

Lallensack, J. N., Farlow, J. O., Falkingham, P. L. (2021) A new solution to an old riddle: elongate dinosaur tracks explained as deep penetration of foot, not plantigrade locomotion. Palaeontology, 65(1).

Romano, M. & Pignatti, J. (2021) The fossil merchant from Verona: the first written testimony of paleontological forgery in Italy. Online Publications of the Italian Geological Society, 55, 54-63.

Burnett, S. E. (2019) A Stegosaur Carving on the Ruins of Ta Prohm? Think Again. Skeptical Inquirer, 43(4).

Senter, P. J. (2019) Dragon Hoaxes: Piltdown Men of Creationism. Skeptical Inquirer, 43(3).

Barnes, R. M. (2018) The Arguments for Creationism and the Arguments for Evolution: A Study in Contrasts. Skeptic, 23(4).

Kim, J. Y. & Lockley, M. G. (2015) Have the Gainri tracks become a Korean Paluxy: problematic influences from creationism. In Y. Zhang, S. Z. Wu and G. Sun (Eds.) Abstracts of the 12th Symposium on Mesozoic Terrestrial Ecosystems, 224-225.

Farlow, J. O., Bates, K. T., Bonem, R. M., Dattilo, B. F., Falkingham, P. L., Gildner, R., Jacene, J., Kuban, G. J., Martin, A. J., O’Brien, M., Whitcraft, J. (2015) Dinosaur Footprints from the Glen Rose Formation (Paluxy River, Dinosaur Valley State Park, Somervell County, Texas). In C. Noto (Ed.) Early-and Mid-Cretaceous Archosaur Localities of North-Central Texas, 13-37.

Numbers, R. L. & Wiley, T. J. (2015) Baptizing Dinosaurs: How Once-Suspect Evidence of Evolution Came to Support the Biblical Narrative. Spectrum, 43(1), 57-68.

Moore, R. (2014) Did Humans Live With Dinosaurs? Excavating “Man Tracks” along the Paluxy River. The American Biology Teacher, 76(4), 243-246.

Moore, R. (2014) People and Places: The “Man Tracks” in Glen Rose. Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 34(2), 3-8.

Branch, G. & Scott, E. C. (2013) Peking, Piltdown, and Paluxy: creationist legends about paleoanthropology. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 6.

Kuban, G. J. (2013) The Alvis Delk Print: An Alleged Human Footprint on a Loose Rock. paleo.cc.

Kim, J. Y., Lockley, M. G., K. S., Seo, S. J., Lim, J. D. (2012) Enigmatic Pterosaur Tracks and Associated Ichnofauna from the Cretaceous of Korea: Implications for the Bipedal Locomotion of Pterosaurs. Ichnos, 19(1-2), 50-65.

Kuban, G. J. (2012) An Alleged Cretaceous Finger. paleo.cc.

Ruffell, A., Majury, N., Brooks, W. E. (2012) Geological fakes and frauds. Earth-Science Reviews, 111(1-2), 224-231.

Ault Jr., C. R. & Dodick, J. (2010) Tracking the Footprints Puzzle: The problematic persistence of science-as-process in teaching the nature and culture of science. Science Education, 94(6), 1092-1122.

Farlow, J. O., O’brien, M., Kuban, G. J., Dattilo, B. F., Bates, K. T. (2010) Dinosaur Tracksites of the Paluxy River Valley (Glen Rose Formation, Lower Cretaceous), Dinosaur Valley State Park, Somervell County, Texas. In Proceedings of the 5th International Conference on Dinosaur Paleontology and its Environment, 41-69.

Kuban, G. J. & Wilkerson, G. (2010) The “Burdick Print”. paleo.cc.

Dunacn, J. A. (2009) Faith Displayed as Science: The Role of the ‘Creation Museum’ in the Modern American Creationist Movement [Honors Thesis, Harvard University]. SSRN.

Moshier, S. O., Maas, D. E., Greenberg, J. K. (2009) From the beginning: faith and geology at evangelical Wheaton College. Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 310(1), 301-316.

Kuban, G. J. (2008) A Russian Paluxy? paleo.cc.

Kuban, G. J. (2007) Do Human Tracks Occur in the Kayenta of Arizona? A Review of a CRSQ Report on Alleged “Humanoid” Tracks in Arizona. paleo.cc.

Gosdin, B. J. (2005) Panther Cave. Somervell Settlers, 11(2), 47-49.

Standish, T. G. (2005) How to Write an Unpublishable Paper. Origins, 58, 3-6.

Brown, C. M. (2004) Hindu and Christian Creationism: “Transposed Passages” in the Geological Book of Life. Zygon, 37(1), 95-114.

Ham, K. (2003) Searching for the ‘magic bullet’: Why do creation-defenders often seem to be too quick to jump onto the latest ‘evidences’? Creation, 25(2), 34-37.

Wise, D. U. (2001) Creationism’s Propaganda Assault on Deep Time and Evolution. Journal of Geoscience Education, 49(1), 30-35.

Wise, D. U. (1998) Creationism’s Geologic Time Scale: Should the scientific community continue to fight rear-guard skirmishes with creationists, or insist that “young-earthers” defend their model in toto? American Scientist, 86(2), 160-173.

Brand, L. R. (1996) The Paradigm of Naturalism, Compared with a Viable Alternative: A Scientific Philosophy for the Study of Origins. Origins, 23(1), 6-34.

Thomas, D. (1996) NBC’s Origins Show. Skeptical Briefs, 6(1).

Hastings, R. J. (1995) A Tale of Two Teeth or, The Best of Teeth, the Worst of Teeth. Creation/Evolution Journal, 15(1), 1-14.

Corum, B. A. (1994) Carl Baugh on the air and in it. Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 14(2), 10-11.

Kuban, G. J. (1994) Elongate Dinosaur Tracks. M.A.P.S. Digest, 17(4), 76-90.

Lippard, J. (1994) Sun Goes Down in Flames: The Jammal Ark Hoax. Skeptic, 2(3), 22-33.

Tanner, W. F. (1994) Human and Not-so-Human Footprint Images on the Rocks. The Paleontological Society Papers, 1, 117-133.

Hastings, R. J. (1992) For Your Information: A Creationist Blunder Table. Houston Geological Society Bulletin, 12(10), 39-41.

Lepper, B. T. (1992) Radiocarbon Dates for Dinosaur Bones? Creation/Evolution Journal, 12(1), 1-9.

Arndts, R. T. (1990) Logic and the Interpretation of Fossils. Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism, 2, 7-14.

Armstrong, J. R. (1989) Seeking Ancient Paths. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 41(1), 33-35.

Hastings, R. J. (1989) Creationists’ “Glen Rose Man” Proves to be a Fish Tooth (As Expected). Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 9(3), 14-15.

Hill, C. A. (1989) Paluxy Mantracks Still Affirmed. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 41(3), 64.

Kuban, G. J. (1989) A Follow-up on Carl Baugh’s science degrees. The Skeptic: Newsletter of the North Texas Skeptics, 3(5).

Kuban, G. J. (1989) A Matter of Degree: An Examination of Carl Baugh’s Credentials. Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 9(6), 15.

Kuban, G. J. (1989) Retracking Those Incredible Man Tracks. Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 9(4).

Stokes, W. L. (1989) Creationism and the Dinosaur Boom. Journal of Geological Education, 37(1), 24-26.

Chadwick, A. V. (1988) Chadwick Replies. Origins, 15(1), 6-7.

Hastings, R. J. (1988) The Rise and Fall of the Paluxy Mantracks. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 40, 144-154.

Roth, A. A. (1988) Creationists Challenge Creationists. Origins, 15(1), 4-5.

Armstrong, J. R. (1987) Creation Evidences Museum. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 7(5), 16-21.

Chadwick, A. V. (1987) Of Dinosaurs and Men. Origins, 14(1), 33-40.

Hastings, R. J. (1987) Creationists’ Tooth Claims Evolve Into a New Fish Story. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 7(5), 18-21.

Hastings, R. J. (1987) Glen Rose Man – Creationists’ ‘Nebraska Man’. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 7(4), 15-16.

Hastings, R. J. (1987) New Observations on Paluxy Tracks Confirm Their Dinosaurian Origin. Journal of Geological Education, 35(1), 4-15.

Hastings, R. J. (1987) Tracking Those Incredible Creationists – The Trail Goes On. Creation/Evolution Journal, 7(2).

Holroyd III, E. W. (1987) International Conference on Creationism. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 23(4), 175.

Monroe, J. S. (1987) Creationism, Human Footprints, and Flood Geology. Journal of Geological Education, 35(2), 93-103.

Anonymous (1986) Of Men, Monsters and Mystery on the Paluxy. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 6(5), 19-20.

Cole, J. R. (1986) The Paluxy Creek Footprints in Pittsburgh. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 6(5), 15-16.

Farlow, J. O. (1986) In the Footsteps of Dinosaurs? Nature, 323(6087), 4-12.

Godfrey, L. R. & Cole, J. R. (1986) Blunder in their footsteps. Natural History, 95(8), 4-12.

Hastings, R. J. (1986) Cores on Paluxy “Mantracks” Signal Their Last Hurrah. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 6(6), 15.

Hastings, R. J. (1986) Tracking Those Incredible Creationists – The Trail Continues. Creation/Evolution Journal, 6(1), 19-27.

Jukes, T. H. (1986) The Paluxy River mystery. Nature, 321, 722.

Kuban, G. J. (1986) A Summary of the Taylor Site Evidence. Creation/Evolution Journal, 6(1), 10-18.

Kuban, G. J. (1986) Review of ICR Impact Article 151. Origins Research, 9(1), 11-13.

Kuban, G. J. (1986) The Taylor Site “Man Tracks”. Origins Research, 9(1), 1-10.

Lemonick, M. B. (1986) Science: Defeat for Strict Creationists. Time, 127(26), 75.

Schadewald, R. (1986) Scientific Creationism and Error. Creation/Evolution Journal, 6(1), 1-9.

Sheaffer, R. (1986) More on the ri and the Paluxy River footprints. Skeptical Inquirer, 10(4).

Thulborn, T. (1986) Creationism: On the tracks of men and money. Nature, 320, 308.

Cole, J. R. (1985) Did Humans and Dinosaurs Live Together in TX? No! Origins Research, 8(2), 6-7.

Cole, J. R., Godfrey, L. R., Schafersman, S. D. (1985) Mantracks? The Fossils Say No! Creation/Evolution Journal, 5(1), 37-45.

Godfrey, L. R. (1985) Foot Notes of an Anatomist. Creation/Evolution Journal, 5(1), 16-36.

Hastings, R. J. (1985) Gould Visits “Mantrack” Sites at Glen Rose. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 5(3), 14-15.

Hastings, R. J. (1985) Tracking Those Incredible Creationists. Creation/Evolution Journal, 5(1), 5-15.

Pewe, T. L. (1985) Prize for Trilobite in Cretaceous Not Yet Earned. Creation/Evolution, 5(1), 15.

Scott, E. C. & Cole, H. P. (1985) The Elusive Scientific Basis of Creation “Science”. The Quarterly Review of Biology, 60(1).

Schadewald, R. (1984/1985) Bible-Science Conference: Emphasis on GeocentricitySkeptical Inquirer, 9(2), 111-113.

Hastings, R. J. (1984) Creation Evidence Museum near Glen Rose, Texas. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 4(6), 20, 23.

Hayward, J. L. (1984) Fossil Proboscidians and Myths of Giant Men. Transactions of the Nebraska Academy of Sciences, 12, 95-102.

Anonymous (1983) Creationists active in the Paluxy River at Glen Rose. Creation/Evolution Newsletter, 3(6), 6.

Edwords, F. (1983) Creation/Evolution Update: Footprints in the Mind. The Humanist, 43(2), 31.

Milne, D. H. & Schafersman, S. D. (1983) Dinosaur Tracks, Erosion Marks, and Midnight Chisel Work (But No Human Footprints) In the Cretaceous Limestone of the Paluxy River Bed, Texas. Journal of Geological Education, 31(2).

Schafersman, S. D. (1983) Raiders of the Lost Tracks: The Best Little Footprints in Texas. The Skeptical Inquirer, 7(3), 2-6.

Blinderman, C. S. (1982) Unnatural Selection: Creationism and Evolutionism. Journal of Church and States, 24(1), 73-86.

Kofahl, R. E. (1982) Paluxy footprints. Creation/Evolution, 3(3), 43-44.

Godfrey, L. R. (1981) An Analysis of the Creationist Film, Footprints in Stone. Creation/Evolution Journal, 2(4), 23-30.

Weber, C. G. (1985) Paluxy Man – The Creationist Piltdown. Creation/Evolution Journal, 2(4).

Zuidema, H. P. (1981) A Survey of Creationist Field Research. Creation/Evolution Journal, 2(4).

Brown, R. H. (1978) Two Reviews of a Comprehensive Review – B. Origins, 5(2), 105-109.

Neufeld, B. (1975) Dinosaur Tracks and Giant Men. Origins, 2(2), 64-75.

Rusch, W. H. (1971) Human Footprints in Rocks. Creation Research Society Quarterly, 7(4), 201-213.3

Bird, R. T. (1939, May) Thunder in His Footsteps. Natural History.

Books and Chapters

Mitchell, S. (2018) A Texas-Sized Challenge to Young Earth Creation and Flood Geology: A Christian Geologist Looks for Answers. Christian Faith Publishing, pp. 113-116, 163.

Moore, R. (2014) Dinosaurs by the Decades: A Chronology of the Dinosaur in Science and Popular Culture. Greenwood, pp. 286-288.

Feder, K. L. (2010) Encyclopedia of Dubious Archaeology: From Atlantis to the Walam Olum. Greenwood Press, pp. 166-168, 219.

Pemberton, S. G., Gingras, M. K., MacEachern, J. A. (2007) Edward Hitchcock and Roland Bird: Two Early Titans of Vertebrate Ichnology in North America. In W. Miller III (Ed.) Trace Fossils: Concepts, Problems, Prospects, pp. 32-51.

Numbers, R. L. (2006) The Creationists: From Scientific Creationism to Intelligent Design (Expanded Ed.). Harvard University Press, pp. 140-144, 227-228, 236, 293-296, 326-327, 367.

Bridgstock, M. (2001) Those Sensational Dinosaur and ‘Human’ Footprints. In M. Bridgstock and K. Smith (Eds.) Creationism: An Australian Perspective, pp. 74-77.

Gould, S. J. (1991) An Essay on a Pig Roast. In Bully for Brontosaurus: Reflections in Natural History. W. W. Norton & Company, pp. 432-447.

Thulborn, T. (1990) Dinosaur Tracks. Chapman and Hall, pp. 299-231.

Kuban, G. J. (1989) Color Distinctions and Other Curious Features of Dinosaur Tracks Near Glen Rose, Texas. In D. D. Gillette and M. G. Lockley (Eds.) Dinosaur Tracks and Traces, 427-440.

Archer, M. (1988) Squaring off Against Evolution: The Creationist Challenge. In D. R. Selkirk and F. J. Burrows (Eds.) Confronting Creationism: Defending Darwin. New South Wales University Press, 103-143.

Roth, A. A. (1988) Creationists Challenge Creationists. Origins, 15(1), 4-5.

Strahler, A. N. (1987) Science and Earth History – The Evolution/Creation Controversy. Prometheus Books, 459-472.

Sloan, R. E. (1983) The Association of “Human” and Fossil Footprints. In J. P. Zetterburg (Ed.) Evolution versus Creationism: The Public Education Controversy. Oryx Press, 354-357.

Films and Audio

Cole, J., Nicolini, P., Godfrey, L. (1984) The Case of the Texas Footprints [Film]. ISHI Films.

Engle, L. & Lucas, L. (1989) God, Darwin, and the Dinosaurs [Film]. PBS NOVA.

CONCLUSION
In reviewing the sources on both sides of the debate regarding the Paluxy River anomalies, a clear disparity emerges between the pro-anomalistic and critical sources in terms of both quantity and quality. This disparity was observed by Ronnie Hastings in the 1980s when he noted that “In terms of gathered data, scientific documentation, accuracy, and corroboration with other sources…(there) is so much more available documentation by scientific investigators (including photos, maps, and videotapes) than there is by creationist investigators…”. (1986b) The pro-anomalistic camp tends to rely on a smaller or more speculative base leaning on interpretations that cannot be confirmed by other observers, published mostly in the private press, lack a clear unifying methodology, and lack the reinforcement that peer review could provide them. Many of their early works, notably in the case of John Morris and the Institute for Creation Research, present claims that have simultaneously been walked back by authors only to later be re-endorsed, making for a shifting narrative over time (see Appendix A, as well as Hastings, 1986b; Kuban, 1986b; 2022a; and Numbers, 2006). In contrast, the critical sources are more numerous, better substantiated and corroborated, and integrate well with integrated models of geology.

In summary, this bibliography highlights a clear division not only in the amount of research produced but also in its reliability. The pro-anomalistic sources, while fascinating from a historical and cultural perspective, lack the rigor found in the critical sources, which continue to provide the most plausible explanations for the Paluxy River anomalies. Hopefully, this bibliography can serve those interested in the Paluxy’s history and allow for an informed evaluation of the primary sources offered by both sides.

Footnotes

  1. A 1984 bibliography by Walter and Valeria Lang (Two Decades of Creationism: From 1963 to 1983) lists the tape as being produced/made available by Genesis Institute while later sources such as Glen Kuban identify the tape as credited to Carl Baugh’s Baptist “college” on his paleo.cc website.
  2. Sources that are highlighted denote sources that are pro-young-Earth creationism that reject the Paluxy tracks/anomalies despite being predisposed or expected to accept them.
  3. In Rusch’s paper, he said that he planned to investigate the Paluxy tracks further and, should they prove to be human, he would publish a follow-up on his findings. He never published that follow-up, implying he did not think they were human.

APPENDICES

Appendix A – Miscellaneous Sources

The John Morris “Retraction”

I chose not to include the saga of John Morris and the Institute for Creation Research above due to the back-and-forth nature of the situation. John D. Morris was the son of Henry M. Morris, and wrote perhaps the most definitive creationist book arguing that there were human tracks in the Paluxy River, the 1980 Tracking Those Incredible Dinosaurs…and the People Who Knew Them. Morris’ organization, the Institute for Creation Research, presented itself as the primary organization in defending the “human” track interpretation of the Paluxy tracks. (Kuban, 2022) However, during this same time, Glen Kuban and others had been working diligently to demonstrate the dinosaurian features of the tracks in the river and by the mid-1980s had definitively shown that the tracks were not human. After Kuban sent his articles to Morris and various other members of the ICR along with repeated invitations to look at the evidence he and his co-researchers had uncovered, Morris finally met Kuban in Glen Rose in October 1985 to view the evidence firsthand. By showing Morris that the “human” tracks showed preserved dinosaur toe, claw, and metatarsal impressions, matched dinosaur stride measurements and even revealed hidden three-to (tridactyl) color outlines when cleaned, Kuban managed to get Morris to agree that the best “human trails” looked distinctly dinosaurian and that the case for them being human had “weakened considerably”. (Kuban, 1986a) Shortly thereafter, Morris would publish an article titled “The Paluxy River Mystery” where he would recommend creationists no longer use the Paluxy tracks as an argument for young-Earth creationism, and the Institute for Creation Research pulled Tracking Those Incredible Dinosaurs from publication. (Kuban, 2022) However, Morris complicated things by stopping short of making a full retraction – he instead described the tridactyl color patterns pointed out by Kuban as “baffling” and cited half a dozen other “mysteries” that he thought left the tracks in limbo and required further research. Shortly after Morris published this article, Kuban responded showing that Morris’ “lingering mystery” language was effectively an ad-hoc hedge that allowed him to avoid a complete retraction, and refuted his objections point by point. (Kuban, 1986a)

And it was in this limbo that the Institute for Creation Research’s position stayed for decades – 30 years later, Morris published an equally confusing article titled “Paluxy River: The Tale of the Trails” that added nothing new to the discussion yet attempted to confirm that the previous evidence cited by creationists was no longer valid while suggesting that the tracks hadn’t been satisfactorily shown to be dinosaurian (even though they had). (Kuban, 2022) This was while the Institute continued to sell material such as Henry Morris’ Scientific Creationism or Henry Morris and John Whitcomb’s The Genesis Flood that openly defended the Paluxy human-track narrative. (Kuban, 2022)

As of 2025, the ICR has swung to the other side of the pendulum and has apparently moved to encourage the human track interpretation in a more open fashion – on pp. 144-145 of the 2022 edition of Henry Morris’ Scientific Creationism, the book recommends John Morris’ Tracking Those Incredible Dinosaurs, along with the 2013 documentary Footprints in Stone: Forbidden History II, to readers who want to know more about the human footprints in the Paluxy River. The documentary presents a case for the footprints that goes far beyond the “mysterious” anomalies cited by John Morris and unequivocally claims that there are definitive human tracks in the Paluxy River, making the ICR’s previous semi-retractions even more confusing in the face of this contemporary endorsement of the human track narrative. It should be noted that even though the ICR no longer sells John Morris’ book, none of the footnotes point this out or clarify the ICR’s current position. Perhaps the ICR will make a future statement where it comes down definitively on one side or the other – I’ve considered writing them to ask about the discrepancy in person, and will update this article if I get a response.

– The Westcott Notes

While compiling sources, I found two PDF files hosted on the website of the Sanford Westcott Foundation, a ministry founded by psychologist Dr. Robert S. Westcott. (2014a; 2014b) These documents, along with accompanying slideshows, provide passing reference to Westcott’s field investigations at the Paluxy River. It appears that he took at least two field trips to the River, once in 1964 and again in 1971, and was advocating for the tracks being human as recently as 2014, shortly before his passing. Sadly, as far as I could tell, Westcott never made his full field notes available publicly. However, his investigations date back to some of the earliest conducted by creationists, among the likes of Cecil Dougherty and Fred Beierle in the 1960s and 1970s.

  • Westcott, R. S. (2014) Fossil Evidence Evaluated. Sanford Westcott Foundation.
  • Westcott, R. S. (2014) Anthropology: The Evolution or Creation of Man? Sanford Westcott Foundation.
  • Westcott, R. S. (1971) Field Notes of an Investigation of Human, Sabertooth Tiger, and Megathere Tracks in Cretaceous Limestone of the Paluxy River, Glen Rose, Texas, 1971. Sanford Westcott Foundation.
  • Westcott, R. S. (1964) Field Notes of an Investigation of Human, Sabertooth Tiger, and Megathere Tracks in Cretaceous Limestone of the Paluxy River, Glen Rose, Texas, 1964. Sanford Westcott Foundation.

The Creation Evidence Museum’s “Taylor Track Video”

This entry was included in Paul Heinrich’s Paluxy References, but no other information was provided and unlike Baugh’s other tape Enemies Survived Together for a While, this one isn’t mentioned in any secondary sources that might give a better idea of what the tape contains, what it was about, etc. Aaron Judkins, a close associate of Baugh, uploaded a now-privated video on his Rumble page titled Creation Evidence Museum – 1988, which appeared to be a digital upload of a 1988 VHS tape that features Baugh and several others promoting the man-track interpretation at the Taylor Trail, but I’m not sure if this was what Heinrich was referring to. If it is, I’ll publish a digital copy I saved and link it in the bibliography above under the same title.

Creation-Evolution Literature Database Paluxy References

While searching the Creation-Evolution Literature Database, I found several articles from that I could not find print or digital copies of and, even though they seem to be defending the man-track interpretation, was not sure where to categorize them. If anyone has access to these papers, please feel free to contact us with copies.

Appendix B – Selected Newspaper Articles

Malcolm, T. (2024, August 4) For 40 years, dinosaurs and creationists have lived together in Texas. Houston Chronicle.

Smith, S. (2012, April 11) Creationism Among the Dinosaur Footprints in Glen Rose. Texas Monthly.

Farlow, J. (2012, February 2) Creationism lacks scientific pedigree. The Journal Gazette. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Kaiser, L. A. (2005, September 24) Small Texas museum promotes ‘creation science’. San Antonio Express-News. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Beets, G. (2005, August 5) Creationism Alive and Kicking in Glen Rose. The Austin Chronicle.

Geller, U. (1998, December 2) The funny thing about fossils. The Times. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Smith, G. (1998, November 2) PREACHER-GEOLOGIST RAPS THEORY OF EVOLUTION. Watertown Daily Times. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Henry, K. (1996, December 12) Footprints of Fantasy. Dallas Observer.

Anonymous (1989, June 30) CREATIONISTS ADMIT TRACKS IN RIVER BELONG TO DINOSAURS. The Columbus Dispatch. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Guiterrez-Mier, J. (1987, August 9) ARTIFACT EXCITES CREATIONISTS: Some doubt tooth found near dinosaur fossils in human. The Dallas Morning News, p. 3. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Raymo, C. (1986, November 17) DINOSAURS AND CREATIONISTS. The Boston Globe, p.44. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Golden, G. (1986, October 26) OF MEN, MONSTERS AND MYSTERY ON THE PALUXY: Did men walk with dinosaurs? For decades, creationists, skeptics and fanatics gathered by the river in search of the answer (2 of 2). The Dallas Morning News. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Golden, G. (1986, October 26) OF MEN, MONSTERS AND MYSTERY ON THE PALUXY: Did men walk with dinosaurs? For decades, creationists, skeptics and fanatics gathered by the river in search of the answer (1 of 2). The Dallas Morning News. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Long, K. R. (1986, August 10) Dinosaur Tracks Stop Creationists in Their Tracks. The Times-Picayune, p. 12.

Pugh, J. (1986, July 16) Heaven and Earth Yield Evidence to Support the Beliefs of Evolutionists. St. Petersburg Times, p. 7E, 9E.

Ogle, A. (1986, July 14) Tracking the Man Track. The Edmonton Journal, p. C2.

Wilford, J. N. (1986, June 29) DINOSAURS-ERA ‘MAN TRACKS’ DISPUTED AS FUNDAMENTAL MISTAKE. Chicago Tribune. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Gayle, G. (1986, June 22) Troublesome Tracks: Dispute Still Simmers Over Glen Rose Fossil Prints. Dallas Morning News, p. 47A, 53A.

Anonymous (1986, June 19) Expert: Footprints may not be human. The El Paso Times, p. 12A. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Boyer, S. (1986, June 19) Tracks in Time – Dinosaur Footprints Put Hobbyist in Midst of Controversy. Sun Times Sentinel, p. A1, A12.

Wilford, J. N. (1986, June 18) Evolution vs Creation: Imprint find shows dinosaurs one foot up on creationists. El Paso Herald Post, p. D11. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Anonymous (1986, June 18) MAN DIDN’T ROMP WITH DINOSAURS ANALYSIS OF FOSSIL FOOTPRINTS DEBUNKS: CREATIONIST THEORY. The Orlando Sentinel. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Anonymous (1986, June 17) FOOTPRINT CLUES SOLVE RIDDLE – MAN DIDN’T ROMP WITH DINOSAURS. The Orlando Sentinel. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Wilford, J. N. (1986, June 17) Fossil prints may frustrate creationists. Houston Chronicle. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Wilford, J. N. (1986, June 17) FOSSILS OF ‘MAN TRACKS’ SHOWN TO BE DINOSAURIAN. The New York Times. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Wilford, J. N. (1986, June 17) New look at dinosaur fossils undermines creationist theory. The Houston Chronicle. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Martin, C. (1986, June 5) On the Trail of Dinosaurs. Denver Post, p. 1C, 5C.

Jones, J (1986, February 22) Human tracks sprouting dinosaur toes. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p. 21A-22A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Krebs, M. A. (1985, August 11) Theologian Says Man, Dinosaurs Walked Together. Waco Tribune-Herald, p. 1A, 6A.

Baker, A. (1984, October 25) Dinosaur excavation assailed: Scientist says work is damaging bones. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p.17A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Potter, K. (1984, October 20) Third dinosaur fossil find reported: Creationist hopes to find signs humans and giant lizards coexisted. Fort Worth-Star Telegram, p. 31A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Curtis, T. (1984, October 10) Paluxy Track Fuels Man’s Origin Debate. Cleburne Times Review, 74(240), 1.

Potter, K. (1984, October 3) Paluxy creationist stands by his claim he found footprints. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p. 3D. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Anonymous (1984, September 28) RANCHER DISPUTES CREATIONIST CLAIM OF “MAN TRACKS”. The Dallas Morning News, p.2. Houston Public Library eResources and Articles Search.

Potter, K. (1984, September 27) Glen Rose rancher says ‘man tracks’ a lie. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p.1A-2A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Baker, A. (1984, August 10) Scientific look at bones urged: Paleontologist says objects should go to a university. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p. 19A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Baker, A. (1984, August 9) Bone of contention: Rancher hoping discovery will block plans for Paluxy Reservoir. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p. 13A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Shupe, A. (1984, July 29) Exploring more than the ‘missing link’. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p. 3AA. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Potter, K. (1984, June 20) The curious come for denial of Darwin. Fort Worth Star-Telegram, p.13A, 16A. Houston Public Library Fort Worth Star-Telegram Archive (1902-1991).

Brice, L. (1984, February 13) Evolution is theory. The El Paso Times, p. 4A. Houston Public Library ProQuest Historical Newspapers Archive (The El Paso Times, 1921-Present).

Anonymous (1983, December 31) Creationists pattern museum after ark. The El Paso Times, p. 4D. Houston Public Library ProQuest Historical Newspapers Archive (The El Paso Times, 1921-Present).

Barrinea, M. (1983, July 24) Dinosaur Valley: Where Scientists and Creationists Roam. Dallas Times Herald, Westward Magazine, p. 14FF.

Tolbert, F. X. (1979, July 30) The 7-Foot Woman Had Perfect Teeth. Dallas Morning News, p. 15. Houston Public Library Dallas Morning News Historical Archive (1885-1877).

Phelon, C. (1978, July 2) Human Footprint Collector Steps on Academia’s Toes. The El Paso Times, p. 8-9. Houston Public Library ProQuest Historical Newspapers Archive (The El Paso Times, 1921-Present).

Carter, M. (1973, December 30) Film Disagrees with Evolution. The El Paso Times, p. 9D. Houston Public Library ProQuest Historical Newspapers Archive (The El Paso Times, 1921-Present).

Jack, M. (1968, October 20) Talk of Texas. The Austin Statesman, p. A5. Houston Public Library ProQuest Historical Newspapers Archive (The El Paso Times, 1921-Present).

Leave a comment